The best vegetarian pizza toppings include mushrooms, peppers, onions, aubergine, courgette, artichokes, olives and spinach, paired with vegetarian mozzarella or another suitable cheese. For a balanced pizza, combine one substantial vegetable with something sweet or salty, cook off excess moisture before baking, and finish with fresh herbs.
Which vegetables work best on pizza?
Choose toppings for their flavour and texture rather than adding every vegetable you have. Try these options if you want variety without relying on meat substitutes.
- Mushrooms: Button, chestnut and oyster mushrooms add savoury flavour and a satisfying bite. Brown them in a hot pan before adding them to your pizza.
- Peppers and onions: Peppers add sweetness and a little crunch; red or yellow onions taste sharper raw and sweeter cooked. Slice both thinly if you plan to use them raw.
- Aubergine and courgette: Roasted aubergine gives you a soft, substantial topping, while courgette has a milder flavour. Use thin slices and cook them first unless you shave the courgette into very fine ribbons.
- Artichokes, olives and capers: Use these for tangy or salty flavours that balance mild cheese. Drain them thoroughly, pit the olives and use capers sparingly.
- Spinach and leafy greens: Pair wilted spinach with ricotta and garlic. Add rocket after baking so it keeps its peppery flavour and fresh texture.
- Tomatoes: Choose halved cherry tomatoes for juicy acidity or drained sun-dried tomatoes for a more concentrated flavour. Use either sparingly over tomato sauce.
Vegetarian pizza topping combinations
Pair a rich or mild topping with something sharper so you can taste the contrast. Avoid combining several salty ingredients on the same pizza.
- Tomato, mozzarella and basil: Spread a thin layer of tomato sauce, add drained mozzarella and finish with fresh basil after baking. Choose this combination if you want to keep the focus on the dough and cheese.
- Mushroom, spinach and ricotta: Combine browned mushrooms, squeezed spinach and small spoonfuls of ricotta. Add a little garlic to either a tomato base or a light coating of olive oil.
- Roasted pepper, artichoke and olive: Use tomato sauce and a modest amount of mozzarella. The peppers add sweetness, so you don't need a sweet sauce or glaze.
- Aubergine, tomato and smoked cheese: Pair roasted aubergine with tomato sauce and a smoked cheese labelled vegetarian. Add basil after baking for a fresh contrast.
- Courgette, goat's cheese and lemon: Top a lightly oiled base with prepared courgette and small pieces of vegetarian goat's cheese. Finish with finely grated lemon zest, avoiding the bitter white pith.
Which pizza toppings should you cook first?
Cook off excess moisture before topping your dough. Mushrooms, spinach and thick slices of courgette can release enough water to leave the centre soggy even when the crust has finished baking.
Fry mushrooms in a wide pan with a little oil, leaving enough space for moisture to evaporate. Wilt spinach separately, let it cool, then squeeze it firmly. Roast or pan-fry aubergine until tender, since thick raw slices rarely soften fully during a short pizza bake.
You can add thinly sliced peppers and onions raw if you like some crunch. Cook them first if you prefer a softer texture or sweeter flavour. Let cooked vegetables cool before assembling your pizza so they don't warm and soften the raw dough.
Drain artichokes and other jarred vegetables in a sieve, then blot them dry. Pat fresh mozzarella dry too. You can still end up with a wet centre if you drain the vegetables carefully but add too much liquid with the cheese.
How to choose vegetarian pizza cheese
Check the rennet, not just the type of cheese. Some cheesemakers use animal-derived rennet, which isn't vegetarian. The Vegetarian Society lists animal rennet as an ingredient vegetarians should avoid.
Look for a clear vegetarian label or confirmation that the producer uses microbial or vegetarian rennet. You can use mozzarella, ricotta, goat's cheese or smoked cheese, but don't assume every version is suitable.
Use mozzarella when you want a mild cheese that melts well. Add ricotta in small spoonfuls for creaminess, or use a smaller quantity of a stronger cheese so it doesn't overpower the vegetables. Check grated hard cheese and ready-made pesto as well, since either may contain cheese made with animal rennet.
How to add protein to vegetarian pizza
You can add protein with cheese, tofu, beans or chickpeas. Choose one that suits your other toppings rather than adding several simply to make the pizza more filling.
Crumble firm tofu, season it with olive oil, garlic and oregano, then bake or pan-fry it before adding it to your pizza. For chickpeas, drain and dry them, toss with a little oil and seasoning, and scatter them lightly over tomato sauce with roasted peppers.
Try a thin spread of mashed white beans beneath mushrooms as an alternative to tomato sauce. Keep the mixture thick rather than runny, and spread it thinly so the base can bake properly.
How much topping should you put on a pizza?
For a typical 30 cm pizza, start with two or three main toppings, excluding sauce, cheese and herbs. Leave visible gaps between pieces instead of covering the surface with a thick layer, particularly if you're making a thin base.
Spread the sauce thinly, distribute the cheese, then space the prepared vegetables evenly. Preheat your oven and pizza stone, steel or suitable baking tray according to the equipment instructions. Heat the baking surface thoroughly to help the underside cook before the toppings dry out.
Add delicate toppings last: rocket, fresh basil, lemon zest and a light drizzle of olive oil usually work best after baking. Taste a piece before adding extra salt, especially if you've used olives, capers or a strongly flavoured cheese.
Sources
- The Vegetarian Society UK (vegsoc.org)